Thursday, January 26, 2006

Bad Floor Wax

As I mentioned a while ago, I'm currently visiting the Center for Computational Science and Engineering at UC Davis. They're located in the Mathematical Sciences Building, which is brand new. It just opened in December. I'm in a large, shared office, which is pretty nice except it doesn't have any windows.

However, the floor wax is pretty terrible. It doesn't stick to the floor. It's new linoleum, and perhaps this is the first time it's ever been waxed. As I roll in and out of my desk (which I need to do fairly often or else the lights go out), the wax flakes off in large pieces. It's not that bad, but somehow I've got it in my head that the wax looks like giant flakes of skin, which grosses me out. I probably read too much Stephen King as a child.

Tuesday, January 24, 2006

Berry Falls Hike

This Saturday my brother and I went on a hike to Berry Falls. A nice description of the hike and a bunch of photos is here. It was very, very cool. The falls were great and redwoods are amazing. We saw lots of slow-moving salamanders on the trails. I think they were California Newts. The coast range variety Taricha torosa torosa. Whatever the were they were fun. We also saw some California quail. All in all, a very nice day. The California coast is pretty amazing.

Wednesday, January 18, 2006

Mechanical Contrivium: College of the Atlantic

As is too often the case, I'm blogging when I should be doing other work. In this case, I'm editing a paper that I've been in various stages of writing for three years. Yup. Three years. Anyway, I discovered The Mechanical Contrivium, a site that will automatically generate trivia about a person or a thing that you enter. It's a little bit like mad libs, but easier and a lot more fun.

I entered "college of the atlantic", and got the following:

Ten Top Trivia Tips about College of the Atlantic!

  1. The moon is 400 times closer to the Earth than College of the Atlantic, and 400 times smaller!

  2. If you lick College of the Atlantic ten times, you will consume one calorie.

  3. College of the Atlantic can usually be found in nests built in the webs of large spiders.

  4. College of the Atlantic is the smallest of Jupiter's many moons!

  5. During the reign of Peter the Great, any Russian nobleman who chose to wear College of the Atlantic had to pay a special College of the Atlantic tax!

  6. Without its lining of College of the Atlantic, your stomach would digest itself.

  7. 99 percent of the pumpkins sold in the US end up as College of the Atlantic.

  8. In a pinch, the skin from a shark can be used as College of the Atlantic!

  9. It's bad luck for a flag to touch College of the Atlantic.

  10. In Ancient Egypt, people wore glittery eyeshadow made from the crushed shells of College of the Atlantic.
I am interested in - do tell me about



Not bad. Item 9 is particularly accurate. Ok. Back to editing.

Thursday, January 12, 2006

Energy Conservation Gone Awry

I'm currently visiting the center for Computational Science and Engineering at UC Davis for a few weeks. They are located in a new mathematical sciences building. The lights in the office I'm sharing are turned off and on automatically by a motion detector device. The idea, I suppose, is that the lights will turn off if nobody is around, thus conserving energy.

This makes a lot of sense for a hallway and maybe even a bathroom. If nobody's there, no need to have the lights on. However, this doesn't work in a room full of theoretical physicists. See, the harder I work, the less I move. When I'm getting work done, I barely move at all. So the lights keep going off. Every two minutes and thirty seconds. To get the lights to go back on I have to roll away from my desk a little bit so I'm not obscured by my desk partition and wave at the motion sensor. I suppose this is decent exercise. But it gets a little annoying. Fortunately, there's a small light on my desk. So when the main lights go out I'm not in total darkness. I've pretty much given up using the main lights and just use the desk light now.

Anyway, this isn't a major inconvenience. But one has to wonder: whose great idea was it to have lights operated by motion detectors in the offices of a math building?

Wednesday, January 11, 2006

Reviewing done

Just finished a referee report on a paper that I should have finished a long time ago. Yay for me.

Now that I'm done patting myself on the back, time to work on some of the other things I should have finished a long time ago.

Sunday, January 08, 2006

Disturbing Wrapping Paper

So, I'm at my Mom's, and I just wrapped some Christmas presents. She has some really strange wrapping paper. The basic motif is a collection of round white and red swirled circular peppermint hard candy things. There are also white and green swirled candy things. Some of the peppermints are adorned with smiley faces licking their lips. The peppermints look quite psychedelic. The background is green. Also printed on the background at regular intervals is "Sweet & Sticky!" (Yes, with the exclamation point.)

Yikes. Yikes. Yikes. The entire effect is disturbing. It looks like it could form the basis of a psy-trance/hard house rave flyer. I've never done acid, but the paper sure looks like it was inspired by a bad trip. The smiley faces look quite maniacal. I could easily imagine that they would scare small children. And my Mom's got a lot of this stuff -- we'll be seeing it for years.

Anyway, I made sure to wrap my brother's present in the disturbing paper.

Sunday, January 01, 2006

Saturday, December 31, 2005

Scientific Publishing, Part I: Peer Review and Journal Basics

Around a week ago I was asked to review an article for a journal. For reasons that I'll explain subsequently, this request has prompted me to do some research about certain aspects of academic publishing. Rather than try to capture all my thoughts in one entry, I'll aim to write a series of shorter pieces. So, if all goes well, this will be the first in a continuing series.

I thought I should begin with some of the basic mechanics of academic journals. To those who have submitted work to peer-reviewed journals, I don't think this will be anything new. However I suspect that some undergraduates or prospective COA students read this blog, and I've found that many undergraduates -- quite understandably -- don't have that much awareness of the nuts and bolts of academic publishing. (Actually, I really have almost no idea who, if anyone, reads this blog.)

My experience with peer-reviewed journals is almost exclusively in physics and some interdisciplinary chaos/complexity type journals. I've submitted about a dozen papers to such journals, and I've refereed about twenty papers. (This hardly qualifies me as an expert referee or as a productive author.) I think that my comments apply to other fields of science, and much of the social sciences, as well.

Publishing articles in peer-reviewed journals is the standard way academic research results are communicated. The process works as follows. Let's say I have some results that I've written up as a paper. I choose a journal to submit my paper to, and I send a copy to the journal. Usually, this submission is done electronically. Over 90% of the papers sent to the Physical Review series of journals are submitted electronically, and I suspect that this figure is similar for other physics and math journals. I've never submitted a paper copy to a journal, nor do I know anyone who has done so recently.

Anyway, the editor or an associate editor of the journal gets the paper and likely gives it a quick read. Unless the editor deems the paper to be clearly unfit for publication, he or she chooses a few people to serve as referees for the submission. Often, authors will suggest referees when submitting their paper. The editor is under no obligation to choose the suggested referees, of course. The editor may choose other experts in the particular area that the paper is in, and/or may select referees from the list of references in the submission.

The paper then goes out to the referees who are asked to write a brief report and recommend publication, rejection, or something in between. The referees are anonymous to the authors of the submission. As a matter of practice, however, it is often not too hard to figure out who your referees are. In scientific fields, almost always the authors of the submission are known to the referees. In social sciences it is more common for the authors' names to be left off the copy of the manuscript that goes to the referees.

Once the editor has received the referee reports, he or she makes a decision regarding publication and communications this to the author, along with the referee reports. The author may be asked to make changes to the manuscript, in which case the referees may be asked to re-review the revised paper. The author also has an opportunity to respond to the referees comments. As one can imagine, this process can sometimes get a little messy. But eventually this process ends and the paper is either accepted or not.

Much could be said about the biases and problems inherent in the peer review process. It can be a nasty business and there is much room for abuse of the process. There are some good arguments that the peer review process doesn't work and should be done away with or radically modified. But this isn't my main concern here.

(For more about the review process, here are the editorial policies and description of the review process for Physical Review E and Chaos, two journals that I've published in. And wikipedia has a entry about peer review that seems pretty accurate to me.)

Moving on, then, let's assume that the article is accepted for publication. The editors and their staff may do some light editing of the manuscript. In my experience, they've done very little, but they have caught a few typos and formatting glitches. They've also introduced errors, but on balance they do more good than harm. The article is then formatted for publication. I don't think this requires much work, since almost all articles are submitted electronically and, in physics at least, most of these are submitted in LaTeX, which is a typesetting program that produces publication-quality formatting. There is some labor involved in making the articles look good enough for publishing, but not much.

Then, the journal is published and sent to subscribers. Most scientists don't subscribe to journals; we read them through our libraries. Some scientists might subscribe to journals directly relevant to their field, but I'd guess that few subscribe to more than one or two, if any at all. I subscribe to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher. But I'm interested in these journals because they discuss matters of interest to my teaching. I don't subscribe to any journals that publish papers I might be interested in because they related to my research.

In any event, the result is that a journal full of articles appears in the library, and/or a the new issue is made available online. What good is this system? What is the value of the journal? What services do the journal and its publisher provide the academic community? To this last question, I can think of several answers.

First, the publisher provides a nicely formatted, bound issue of a journal. This journal is a nice physical object; most journals have a pleasing heft to them, even if they do resemble telephone books at times. This physical object can be stored in libraries, or in offices or people's homes, and can be carried around and read. As for the formatting of individual articles, I'm not sure that the publisher is adding that much value. Without too much difficulty most physicists can format articles that look as good as those in a journal.

Second, the journal provides the service of peer review. Why is this important? Peer-reviewed publications are the coin of the realm in academic science. The number of publications in peer-reviewed journals is one of the first things looked at when evaluating a scientist. This is especially so for junior scientists who are up for promotion and/or tenure at universities that emphasize research and for graduate students and post-docs who are applying for jobs. The widespread practice of using a count of peer-reviewed publications as a proxy for scientific quality is, for better or worse, a fact of life. This isn't going to change anytime soon. So, peer review is an important service to the academic community.

It could also be argued that, through the peer-review process, journals maintain quality. Because all articles in a journal have been through peer review, they will be scientifically sound and more worth reading than just some random stuff someone might, say, post on a website. There is surely some truth to this, but I suspect not much. In areas that I work in, I feel pretty compentent to judge the value of an article; peer-reviewed or not, I think I can detect
garbage pretty well. Alas, I've read lots of really bad articles in peer-reviewed journals. Good journals, too. Peer review might be more valuable for areas I don't know much about. But again, I think most scientists develop their own critical eye pretty quickly; just because it's been peer-reviewed doesn't mean it's correct or interesting.

Third, through publication in journals articles are indexed in databases. If an article is published in most any journal, it will get picked up by the science citation index, INSPEC, and other databases. Researchers then use these databases to find articles.

Fourth, journals provide electronic access to papers. Individual researchers could do this, but not everyone has a webpage. And a publisher's website is likely much more permanent than any individual scientist's web page.

Before concluding, let's note some services that journals don't provide:

  1. Scientific research and writing. The journal doesn't do the research, and authors are not paid for their submissions. In fact, some journals charge authors to publish their work.

  2. Peer-review. Yes, the journal facilitates peer review, but the journal doesn't actually do the work. As I've lamented previously, referees are not paid for their work.

So, all this leads me to the main questions: How much should a journal cost? (Remember, authors and reviewers work for free.) What is reasonable to charge a library for a paper and/or online subscription to a monthly journal that contains, say, around thirty research articles each issue? Are there significant differences in journal prices? Have journal prices changed over time? Do better journals cost more?

Thursday, December 29, 2005

IRS and the Quadratic Formula

I spent a while tonight writing some text for the COA academic website. It's an important task, but I have a hard time getting psyched to do it.

Anyway, a while back I stumbled across the following: If the IRS had discovered the quadratic formula... by Daniel Velleman. Amusing.